As Cheryl Cooper's birthday approaches, she believes her new life in Sugarcreek, Ohio, is the best gift she's ever received. She loves running the Swiss Miss gift shop and even though there have been a few bumps along the way, she feels content. But an unexpected discovery in an abandoned laundry chute raises disturbing questions that could point to a woman who disappeared decades ago. Could she have been murdered? Is there a connection between her and the building that houses the beloved shop? As Cheryl begins a search for answers, her parents and brother come to town for a visit. Family tensions and disturbing clues from the past mix together to send her down a path that will challenge her personal relationships and finally solve an old mystery.